The Black Death Reality Check: Why 99% of Modern Preppers Would Have Been Corpses

June 25, 2025
by Jason Salyer
GoOn3.com is provided for entertainment purposes only. Read our Entertainment & Liability Disclaimer.

The Black Death Reality Check: Why 99% of Modern Preppers Would Have Been Corpses

Picture this: You're sitting in your suburban home, scrolling through prepper forums, feeling pretty good about your 72-hour kit and that case of MREs you bought last year. But what if I told you that if the Black Plague hit tomorrow, most of us would be dead within weeks? Not from the disease itself, but from the same deadly mistakes that killed 60% of Europe in the 1300s.

I'm not trying to scare you. I'm trying to wake you up.

After years of studying real-world survival scenarios from the backwoods of Georgia to working with Naval Special Operations, I've learned one brutal truth: survival isn't about having the coolest gear. It's about understanding what actually kills people when everything goes sideways.

And the Black Death? It's the ultimate case study in what separates the survivors from the statistics.

The Famine That Set the Stage for Mass Death

Here's what nobody talks about when they mention the plague: Europe was already starving when the disease arrived. The Great Famine of 1315-1317 had wiped out crops, killed livestock, and emptied food stores. People were hanging on by a thread when the Black Death showed up to finish the job.

When your body's already starved of real nutrients, your immune system doesn't stand a fighting chance. It's like trying to bench press 300 pounds after not eating for three days. You're going to fail, and it's going to hurt.

But here's the kicker...

We're facing the exact same problem today, just wrapped in different packaging. Americans are the most overfed, undernourished population in human history. We're stuffed with ultra-processed garbage but starved of the nutrients our bodies actually need to fight off threats.

Your gut health determines your immune response. And if you're living on energy drinks, fast food, and whatever's convenient, you're setting yourself up for failure just like those medieval Europeans who thought they could survive on spoiled grain and hope.

Why Europe's "Shelter in Place" Strategy Was a Death Sentence

Medieval Europeans made a fatal mistake that modern preppers are still making: they clustered together and tried to ride it out in place. They packed into filthy cities with no plumbing, shared water sources, and dumped their waste in the streets where they lived.

Sound familiar? How many preppers do you know who think they'll just hunker down in their subdivision when things get bad?

These people had no understanding of basic hygiene or disease transmission. They shared everything contaminated water, contaminated air, contaminated living spaces. They stayed put because moving seemed too hard, too risky, too uncomfortable.

Want to know the secret that changed everything?

The groups that survived knew when to get out. They understood that sometimes the biggest risk isn't leaving your comfort zone it's staying in it when everyone around you is dying.

The Mongol Advantage: Why Nomads Outlasted City Dwellers

Watch the full video below

Here's where it gets interesting. The Mongols might have been the ones who weaponized the plague, launching infected corpses over city walls during the siege of Kaffa. Talk about early biological warfare. But they didn't suffer nearly as much as the Europeans they were fighting.

Why? Because they lived completely differently.

The Mongols were nomadic. They spread out. They didn't share water sources with thousands of other people. They didn't rely on crowded trade centers. And here's something most people miss they ate fermented dairy and vegetables that kept their gut health strong.

No fancy probiotics or health coaches needed. Just traditional foods that had been keeping people alive for centuries.

Their lifestyle was their survival strategy. While Europeans were crammed together in cities, literally marinating in their own filth, the Mongols were mobile, spread out, and eating foods that supported their immune systems.

The most dangerous mistake? It's not what you think...

It's assuming that your current lifestyle and location will protect you when systems collapse. If you can't move, can't adapt, and can't live differently when everything changes, you're planning to be a statistic.

Underground Storage: The Medieval Prepper's Secret Weapon

One thing the survivors got right was food storage. They buried sealed clay pots underground to keep grains, dried meats, and fermented vegetables safe from pests and temperature swings. Simple technology, but it worked.

Today's preppers get caught up in fancy freeze-dried meals and mylar bags, but miss the fundamental principle: store deep, live light, and make every space count.

I've seen apartment dwellers turn five-gallon food buckets into bed frames, stacking them under plywood and a mattress. It's not my style, but it's creative problem-solving. The medieval mindset was similar work with what you have, maximize every resource, and think beyond the obvious.

Here's what nobody tells you about storage...

It's not just about having food. It's about having the right foods that will keep you strong when your body is under stress. Those medieval survivors weren't just storing calories they were storing nutrition that would support their immune systems during the worst of times.

Ancient Remedies That Actually Worked

Long before anyone understood bacteria or viruses, people used garlic for its infection-fighting properties. They cleaned wounds with vinegar and drank it to stay healthy. They fermented foods not just for preservation, but because it kept their bodies strong.

The famous "Four Thieves" story tells of robbers who looted plague victims without getting sick. Their secret? A mixture of vinegar, clove, rosemary, thyme, and other herbs applied to skin and clothing. Myth or not, modern science proves these herbs have antimicrobial properties.

Survival back then didn't look like combat. It looked like common sense, resourcefulness, and understanding that your body is your most important piece of equipment.

The Reality Check Modern Preppers Need

You don't need to live in a medieval castle to learn from the Black Death. But you do need to understand what actually kills people when systems collapse.

It's not the initial disaster. It's the cascade of failures that follow malnutrition, poor sanitation, overcrowding, and the inability to adapt when everything you thought you knew stops working.

Are you making this mistake?

If your prep strategy is a shelf of canned goods from 2020, bottled water, and a plan to hunker down in your current location no matter what, you're not prepared. You're just hopeful.

And hope isn't a strategy.

What Separates Survivors from Statistics

The people who survived the Black Death shared common traits:

They adapted their lifestyle before they had to. They understood that location matters. They prioritized gut health and immune support through real food. They had systems for sanitation and waste management. They knew when to move and when to stay put.

Most importantly, they didn't wait for someone else to save them. They took responsibility for their own survival.

Which camp are you in? The one that thinks modern conveniences will always be there, or the one that's building real resilience for when they're not?

Take Action Before You Need To

The Black Death teaches us that preparation isn't about stockpiling gear. It's about building systems and habits that keep you alive when everything else fails.

Start with your gut health. If you're living on processed food and energy drinks, you're already behind. Move to real nutrition fermented foods, quality proteins, and vegetables that support your immune system.

Evaluate your location. Can you spread out if you need to? Do you have access to clean water that doesn't depend on municipal systems? Can you manage waste and sanitation without modern conveniences?

Build your knowledge base. Learn traditional food preservation. Understand basic herbal remedies. Know how to clean and disinfect without running to the store.

What's your take on this? Are you building real resilience, or just collecting gear and hoping for the best?

The Black Death killed millions, but it didn't kill everyone. The survivors weren't lucky they were prepared. They lived differently, thought differently, and adapted when others couldn't.

The question isn't whether you'll face a crisis. The question is whether you'll be ready when it arrives. And based on what history teaches us, most people won't be.

But you don't have to be most people.

The Bottom Line: The Black Death wasn't just a medieval problem it was a masterclass in what happens when unprepared people face systemic collapse. The survivors didn't have better luck; they had better habits, better nutrition, and better adaptability. If you're serious about preparedness, stop focusing on gear and start building the lifestyle that keeps you alive when everything else fails.

P.S. Share this newsletter with someone who needs to hear it. The prepping and survival community is filled with fantasies. Let's spread some reality instead.

Check Out My Recommended Gear & Supplies Explore the gear and supplies I personally use and trust. When you purchase through my Amazon storefront and other affiliates, I earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. These small commissions help support the creation of informative, free content for you to enjoy.

Essential Links:

  • Wazoo Survival Gear: https://wazoosurvivalgear.com/?aff=ON3 (Discount code: GOON32025)
  • Bear Forest Knives:
    • On3 EDC: https://www.bearforestknives.com/collections/production/products/on-three-edc
    • On3 Ulu: https://www.bearforestknives.com/collections/production/products/pre-order-now
    • On3 Primitive: https://www.bearforestknives.com/products/on-three-primitive-reserve-yours-now
  • Exotac: https://www.exotac.com/?ref=7d2vkc2wfx (Discount code: On3)
  • PNW Bushcraft: https://www.pnwbushcraft.com/collections/waxed-canvas-bags/products/drawstring-cinch-pack-by-pnwbushcraft

Want more no-nonsense survival and prepper advice? Follow me for free resources:

  • Substack: Subscribe at https://on3ready.substack.com/p/youtube for weekly newsletters and early threat warnings
  • YouTube: Detailed tutorials and gear reviews at https://www.youtube.com/@ONThree/videos
  • Patreon: Private community and exclusive guides at https://patreon.com/OnThree
  • Amazon Storefront: Field-tested gear I actually use at https://www.amazon.com/shop/onthree?ref=prof_v_infl
  • Website: More resources at GoOn3.com
  • Fitness Channel: Physical preparedness at https://youtube.com/@fitonthree
  • Apparel: Stylish gear at https://on-three.creator-sprin

 

Free E-Book

Don't Get Caught Unprepared - DOWNLOAD THE FREE EBOOK :

Tried and Tested: 6 Life-Saving Skills You Should Know Before You Head Outdoors
Free Ebook Form

BLACK FRIDAY SALE
Check It Out
Master the Skills, Own Your Freedom – Unlock Black Friday Savings on 
Top 10 Skills Every Man Should Master!
Learn the essential tools for self-defense, disaster readiness, and off-grid independence at an unbeatable price! TODAY ONLY!

Sign Up for the On3 Email Newsletter

https://www.youtube.com/@onthree
cross